Power v Sharks: how they play, why we lose, what to change

Performance analysis for the senior coach. Source: the full season's tracking and event data (252 games of 240 s, including 20 Power v Sharks games and 116 Sharks games against other clubs). All numbers come from that data; methods, code and a working notebook are in this folder (analysis/, notebook.md).

The short version. The Sharks don't beat us at the centre bounce. They beat us by keeping the ball in our defensive half and waiting for our exit kick. They win the ball back inside our defensive 50 almost 5 times a game and score from 62% of those, in a median 3.5 seconds. That is 13 of their 30 points against us. Our exits fail because our forwards stand still in a flat line and the Sharks' defenders stand 3 m from them, our midfielders crowd the ball, and we kick at the first opportunity (0.4 s) to whoever is nearest. The clubs that beat the Sharks exit the other way: midfielders higher, forwards staggered and leading, and a 30-35 m kick to a player in space. Changing our exit shape and ball use is the priority, and it is where the evidence is strongest.

1. Key findings

  1. The game is lost at our defensive-50 exits. Against the Sharks, half of our possession chains that start in our defensive 50 are lost again inside that 50 (47-52%); only 9-10% end in a score. The eight clubs that trouble the Sharks lose only 15-16% inside the 50 and score from 22-29%. The Sharks then score off those turnovers at 62% (13.0 points a game; against the strong clubs this source is worth only 1.9 points a game). High confidence
  2. The Sharks press by covering our receivers, not by swarming the ball. Pressure on our kicker is ordinary (0.90 on the league's 0-2 scale, close to the 0.8-0.85 other clubs face), but our forwards have a Shark a median 2.9 m away and are an open target only 12% of the time (strong clubs' forwards against the Sharks: 5.3 m and 31%). High confidence
  3. Our forwards don't move and our midfielders crowd the ball. With the ball in our defensive 50, our forwards are leading (>5 m/s) 4% of the time, against 23-24% for the Sharks' and the strong clubs' forwards. They stand in a flat line (6.5 m of depth between them, against about 12 m). We keep 3.9 players within 30 m of our own goal during exits (strong clubs 2.9). High confidence
  4. We kick to contests, at the first opportunity. We release the ball at the 0.4 s minimum on 89-100% of disposals. League-wide, a kick with 10+ m of space at release is kept 91-94% of the time, and one where the nearest defender is 5+ m closer to the landing spot than the teammate only 17-30%. Only 8% of our kicks against the Sharks have more than 6 m of space (Sharks: 35%). High confidence
  5. The clubs that beat the Sharks keep the ball. They keep 72% of their kicks against the Sharks (the other 22 clubs: 56%), hold chains for 8.7 s, take marks and kick for goal from set shots (41% of shots). The Sharks get 13.9 possessions a game against them, against 17.9 against us. Across all 136 Sharks games, the Sharks' margin is lower when the opponent holds the ball beyond the minimum more often (r = -0.54) and kicks over the top from midfield more often (r = -0.57). Moderate confidence
  6. We waste our forward-50 marks. After a mark or free inside 50 against the Sharks, we play on 87% of the time; the Sharks and strong clubs kick for goal 90-96% of the time. None of our 71 shots against the Sharks were set shots, and 38 of them were pressured shots from 30-50 m (goal rates 24% and 15%). High confidence (but a small number of occasions)
  7. What already works: centre bounces. First touch is 50/50, and when we win it our centre chains average 1.37 points against the Sharks, about the same as theirs (1.49). Our m1-to-f2 direct kick out of the centre is our best attacking pattern against them. Moderate confidence
  8. Tested with the league's position rating: on 280 real Power defensive-50 possessions against the Sharks, giving our forwards 3 m more separation and lifting our midfielders 12 m raises the expected value of the best open kick by +4.0 points of next-goal probability per possession (95% CI 3.5-4.5). Picking better targets within the current shape is worth only about +1. Moderate confidence (static test: the Sharks' reaction isn't modelled)
Figure 1. Results. The Sharks are 120-1-15 for the season (+25 a game) and 19-1 against us. The eight 'strong' clubs (Falcons, Magpies, Hawks, Dockers, Cats, Kangaroos, Bulldogs, Titans) account for 13 of the Sharks' 16 non-wins; the Sharks are 19-1-12 against them. We are 0-1-31 against those same eight clubs.

2. The game plan in one table

#ChangeWhy the data says it worksConfidence
1Exit shape. With the ball in our back 50: midfielders sit 35-40 m from our goal (now ~23-24 m), so one extra player is in the 30-60 m band; forwards at two depths (one leading up to 45-55 m, one holding 60-70 m, one wide at |y| 15+), not a flat line of three. Strong clubs set up this way and exit cleanly (Fig. 2, 6, 7, 11). Rating-tool test: +2.1 pts for the midfield move, +1.8 for forward separation, +4.0 combined, per possession (Fig. 13). Open targets per possession rise from 1.0 to 1.6.High confidence on the problem; Moderate confidence on the size of the gain
2Forwards lead, on cue. When we win it back in defence, one forward leads at the ball carrier and one leads into space wide. Target: leading about 20% of the time (now 4%). Separation is what makes a kick safe (Fig. 8, 9). Our forwards are 2.9 m from a Shark; strong clubs' forwards 5.3 m, and our own forwards against other clubs 6.8 m. A static forward is easy to stand next to.High confidence
3Ball carrier: take a second if free, then kick 30-35 m into space. No more 0.4 s releases to the nearest man. Avoid kicks under 20 m out of defence unless the target is unmarked. Aim at the lead, and wide rather than central. Under 20 m our exits are kept 49% of the time; 20-35 m kicks by strong clubs, 81-83%. Holding 0.8-1.2 s after the gather is tackled 2-3% of the time; holding-the-ball frees are rare (29 all season). Beyond 1.2 s the risk rises (8-13%).High confidence
4Kick-ins: wait about 2 s, then 35-40 m to a wide lead. Our kick-ins against the Sharks: taken after 0.4 s, 29 m, central, 58% kept. Strong clubs: 2.0 s, 37 m, wide, 73% kept. The Sharks' own: 39-43 m, 84-92% kept (Fig. 12).Moderate confidence
5From midfield, kick behind the Sharks' last defender when a forward is goal-side of them. Kicks over the last Shark from 47-70 m: chain scores 30% v 19%; from 70-93 m: 45% v 17%, with no loss of retention. We do it 19% of the time from midfield; strong clubs 37%. (From our own 50 it doesn't help, so don't bomb out of defence.)Moderate confidence
6Inside 50: take the set shot. Stop playing on from marks and frees. Same distance (35-45 m): kicking for goal from the mark averages 2.93 points, playing on 1.73. From 45-60 m: 2.20 v 0.99. Only about 0.75 such marks a game against the Sharks, so it's worth roughly a point a game.High confidence on direction, small impact
7Keep the centre-bounce pattern (m1 wins it and kicks direct to f2). Our centre chains score 1.37 points per possession against the Sharks (against other clubs only 0.82); it's the phase where we match them.Moderate confidence
Size of the prize (an upper bound, not a forecast). If our defensive-50 chains performed like the strong clubs' do against the Sharks (0.91 points per chain instead of 0.34; about 10 such chains a game), we would add about 6 points a game. If the Sharks' turnovers inside our 50 fell to the strong-club level (1.0 a game instead of 4.85), they would lose up to about 11 points a game. The two overlap (our lost exits are their forward-50 turnovers), so they don't simply add. Halving the gap to the strong clubs is worth something like 8-9 points a game: enough to turn a 21-point average loss into a contest, but not to make us favourites.

3. How the Sharks play

Attributes are drawn fresh each game and mirrored between the matching players of both clubs, so no club has better players. Everything below is tactical: how they position and how they use the ball.

Figure 2. Average shape by phase against each other (each club drawn attacking left to right). Players don't hold fixed sides (mean signed lateral position is about 0 for every slot), so the lateral marker is mirrored. Top right: the Sharks' press when we have the ball in our defensive 50 (the Sharks' forward 50). Their forwards and midfielders are within about 20-30 m of our goal; their three defenders sit about 62 m from our goal, on top of our forwards.

3.1 With the ball

3.2 Without the ball

Figure 3. Where the Sharks win the ball back (their attacking direction left to right; black dots = that chain ended in a score). Against us, the hot zone is inside our defensive 50 (right-hand side), where they win 4.8 a game and score from 62%. Against the strong clubs they win only 1.0 a game there.

3.3 Stoppages

3.4 Transition

Figure 4. Points per game by where the scoring chain started. Against us the Sharks' biggest source (red) is turnovers inside our defensive 50: 13.0 of their 30.1 points. Against the strong clubs that source is worth 1.9.
Figure 5. Shot maps (attacking right). Stars = set shots. The Sharks get close; the strong clubs shoot from further out but from set shots (39%); we have no set shots and many pressured shots from 30-50 m.

4. Where the Sharks are vulnerable

The best evidence is the eight clubs that took 13 of the Sharks' 16 non-wins. Against them the Sharks average 18.8 to 16.1, a near-even contest.

5. How the Power play now, and why the Sharks beat us

5.1 Our current style (all 136 games, and against the Sharks)

5.2 The losing cycle

  1. The Sharks enter their forward 50 about 9.4 times a game. Our defence copes reasonably: they keep 64% of entries against us, the same as against the strong clubs (66%).
  2. We win it back deep: 6.1 turnovers a game in our back 50, plus 3.85 kick-ins. About 10 exits a game, and almost 20 disposals a game inside our own 50 (strong clubs: under 10).
  3. Our exit kicks are 24 m and central, aimed at spots a Shark is already 9 m from. Only 27% land with no Shark within 5 m; 8% are marked by our player.
  4. The ball dies in our 50: on average our exit chains never get past 38 m from our own goal. The Sharks gather the spill and score within seconds.
Figure 6. How possession chains that start in a club's own defensive 50 end, against the Sharks. Ours (top): half are lost again inside our 50. The strong clubs lose 15-16% there and score from about a quarter.
Figure 7. Kicks out of defensive 50 against the Sharks, by landing point (attacking right). Ours are short and central, landing in the Sharks' press; the strong clubs' are longer and wider, and 32% are marked by their own player.
Figure 8. Forwards while their own team has the ball in its defensive 50. Against the Sharks our forwards are 2.9 m from the nearest opponent, open 12% of the time, and leading 4% of the time. Against other clubs they have more room (6.8 m) but still don't lead, so the 'stand still' habit is ours; the Sharks are simply the side that punishes it.
Figure 9. Left: in every game this season, the share of kicks kept rises steeply with space at release (for kicks of 15 m or more; the same pattern holds within each length band). Right: how much space each side's kicks have. Ours against the Sharks bunch at 0-3 m; the Sharks' and the strong clubs' spread to 10 m+.
Picture of the problem: game 245, 2:12. Five Power players are within 13 m of our goal. Our three forwards stand in a line about 30 m out, each with a Shark beside them. d3 kicks 17 m into the gap, Sharks d1 runs onto it, and they kick a goal 6 s later. That sequence (our defensive-50 kick lost, then a Sharks goal within seconds) happened 27 times in the 20 games. In the broadcast stills below the home side wears red.
Figure 10. Game 245 (Power home, red). Our exit: no lead, no depth, nobody between 13 m and 30 m from our goal.
Figure 11. Game 72 (Falcons, away in blue, won 32-2). The contrast: Falcons midfielders 35 m up the ground, forwards at two depths, f2 leading into the space in front of Sharks d3; a 35 m kick, uncontested mark, set play.

5.3 Kick-ins

Figure 12. Kick-ins (attacking right). Ours are taken immediately, short and central. The strong clubs and the Sharks wait about 2 s and go 37-39 m, wider.

5.4 Why we won game 235, and the close ones

Our one win (18-15) and the three games within 7 points share the same signature: more kicks (31-36 against 18-28 in our seven heaviest losses), more marks (4-8), longer chains (6.4-8.2 s). Across the 20 games our margin correlates with our kick count (r = 0.85), chain length (0.59) and marks (0.55), and against our handball share (-0.42). The Sharks' own kicking accuracy also matters (their kick retention against our margin: r = -0.60), so some of game 235 was their off day. Low confidence (20 games; indicative only)

6. Testing the changes

Method. The league's position rating (tools/rate_position.py) values a position as the probability that each side scores the next goal. I checked it against the database first: on held-ball positions rebuilt from tracking it reproduces the stored rating closely (r = 0.89, mean error 0.08). On loose and in-flight balls it does poorly (r about 0.45, because the flight details can't be fully rebuilt), so I used held-ball positions only.

  1. Valuing each kick option on 280 real moments when we held the ball in our defensive 50 against the Sharks. For every teammate in kicking range (from each kicker's kick power): value = P(kept) x rating if we hold it there + P(lost) x rating if the nearest Shark has it there. P(kept) comes from a model fitted on 16,000 league kicks (it uses space at release, length and pressure: 59% / 77% / 89% kept at 0 / 5 / 10 m of space for a 30 m kick).
  2. Result in the current shape: nearest teammate 0.466, most-open teammate 0.477, most-open forward 0.448 (worse, because the forwards are covered), best available 0.486. Better decisions alone are worth about +1 point.
  3. Result with the shape changed (only our players moved; the Sharks left where they really were): forwards 3 m more separation +1.8; midfielders 12 m higher +2.1; both +4.0 points per possession (standard error 0.3). Open targets go from 1.0 to 1.6 per possession.
  4. A cruder test, rating the static position itself, agrees in direction: midfielders up +0.9, forward separation +0.6. Setting the forwards running at the ball lowers that static rating (-1.3). The rating can't see the next kick, so I don't read this as evidence against leading. The evidence for leading is the retention data in Fig. 8-9.
Figure 13. Rating-tool test: change in the expected value of the best open kick when the Power's exit shape is changed, averaged over 280 real defensive-50 possessions against the Sharks.

Limits of this test: the Sharks don't react in it; a moved Power player still has the Sharks' real positions around them; and the option model values a kick to where a player is, not to where they are leading. It shows which direction is better and the rough size; it isn't a match simulation.

7. Confidence, and what I could not establish

ConclusionConfidenceBasis
Our losses come mainly from turnovers inside our own 50 and the Sharks' instant scoring off themHigh confidenceChains reconcile exactly with the scoreboard (504/504 club-games); 20 games; large, consistent gap to the strong clubs
Space at release drives kick retentionHigh confidence18,790 disposals, every game, monotonic at every kick length
Our forwards are static and covered; the Sharks cover receivers rather than pressing the ballHigh confidenceTracking at 0.5 s, all 20 games
Midfielders higher plus forwards leading will improve our exitsModerate confidenceStrong clubs' example, the retention curve and the rating test. Not observed for the Power itself; the Sharks may adjust
Size of the improvement (+4 points of next-goal probability per possession; 8-9 points a game if we halve the gap)Low confidenceStatic counterfactuals; no reaction modelled
Sharks' defenders match by lane rather than strict man-on-manModerate confidenceMovement correlations; an alternative reading (loose man-on-man that gets lost) fits some of the data
Set shots over playing on inside 50High confidence on direction286 Power forward-50 set plays all season; only 15 against the Sharks
Kick-in changeModerate confidence59 of ours v 48 of the strong clubs' against the Sharks

What I could not establish:

Appendix: definitions and method